Forum

> > CS2D > General > CS2D is back boys
Forums overviewCS2D overviewGeneral overviewLog in to reply

English CS2D is back boys

33 replies
Page
To the start Previous 1 2 Next To the start

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Mami Tomoe
User Off Offline

Quote
And yet, the servers are still empty.

There's only so much advertising can do to a 2D indie game on a 2 decade old engine.
I don't mean to sound pessimistic but it is what it is.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

ModJuicer
Super User Off Offline

Quote
user Mami Tomoe has written
2D indie game on a 2 decade old engine.


The fact that it is 2D or indie isn't too much of a problem. The 2 decade old engine might be, but it isn't a given. Just making a wild guess here, but I think I main big problem is probably not the game itself, but rather the servers, from what I can grasp from other conversations on this site. I would suggest changing the server menu to give more details on servers, like having user ratings and other details that give insight into the quality of any given server. Also, just changing the server menu in general to make it more user-friendly would be preferable. It looks technical, in a way that may be intimidating for potential users. The theme also comes across as lacking, or too minimalistic, in the same way that new corporate logos seem too oversimplified. It more-or less lacks a central theme other than a overall blandness. A bit better font, some more unique logos, and a new layout could likely resolve some of the problems. The colors in the user interface seem to be mainly bright elementary colors or gray, with a lack of deeper, more refined colors. Of course, not all of a game is art but the first (and second, third, fouth..) impression counts.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Mora
User Off Offline

Quote
Need to make good servers with interesting mods and good organised standard servers. When somebody opens sv list and see random servers such as minecraft and other ones where is 1 or 3 players online - is not that much interesting, moreover the content there is bad, old, has bugs and many random scripts without any explanation or hints. Also not many servers has nicely written server info, which means no introduction or description of the server on start - bad?ye.

Mostly potential new players felt interested when downloaded the game, but sv list make them bored. Need to firstly make good servers with gud content so these new players wont leave it that fast.
/sounds okay but nobody wanna do that. I already did IRANTOWN: Reborn with fan team but huh, 4-10 players online in total, idk.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

ModJuicer
Super User Off Offline

Quote
I was considering recommending setting standards and guidelines for servers in the last post, but I just didn't because I was unsure if it was a good enough idea to include. Since you mentioned it, I guess I am not alone in that line of thinking, so it should probably be considered seriously. Also, there should be a specific label in the server list to show which servers reach these standards. The whole server list should be overhauled and significant improvements should be made, in my opinion. It is literally the medium the player uses to join any given online game, so it should be top priority.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Mami Tomoe
User Off Offline

Quote
user ModJuicer has written
user Mami Tomoe has written
2D indie game on a 2 decade old engine.

The fact that it is 2D or indie isn't too much of a problem.

Well yes, I meant it's a problem as a whole.
Compare it to a game like CS1.6 which is not an indie game but is also on an older engine.
Get my vibe?


user ModJuicer has written
Just making a wild guess here, but I think I main big problem is probably not the game itself, but rather the servers, from what I can grasp from other conversations on this site.

Actually no. Servers are just the ones taking the blame for the bigger problem; we can't make decent servers on a game that rarely ever gets updates and has a fairly limited (and slow) Lua interface. Time and time again I tried to exceed what CS2D is capable of (like my GTA mod or my Terraria mod), and CS2D just said no.
Not to mention the fact we have little to no protection VS. denial of service attacks (whether on the servers or on the game server itself).
So when a server does get players, it won't last for long.
That is, if it does ever get players.
Even if you created the most amazing server, it will just get flooded to the ground.
Did I mention hackers? I think you can guess what I have to say about those.


user ModJuicer has written
I would suggest changing the server menu to give more details on servers, like having user ratings and other details that give insight into the quality of any given server. Also, just changing the server menu in general to make it more user-friendly would be preferable. It looks technical, in a way that may be intimidating for potential users. The theme also comes across as lacking, or too minimalistic, in the same way that new corporate logos seem too oversimplified. It more-or less lacks a central theme other than a overall blandness. A bit better font, some more unique logos, and a new layout could likely resolve some of the problems. The colors in the user interface seem to be mainly bright elementary colors or gray, with a lack of deeper, more refined colors. Of course, not all of a game is art but the first (and second, third, fouth..) impression counts.

While it's true that the game UI looks awful even by GoldSrc standards, I doubt @user DC has any plans to change it (as I've already asked before, and since @user DC is finished with the game).


user Mora has written
Need to make good servers with interesting mods

As we've been doing for the past decade, and yet the game is dead.


user Mora has written
good organised standard servers

We have too many of those.


user Mora has written
When somebody opens sv list and see random servers such as minecraft and other ones where is 1 or 3 players online - is not that much interesting

And yet, only those servers get regular players.
Maybe they're just milking whatever bit of fun is left in the game.


user Mora has written
moreover the content there is bad, old, has bugs and many random scripts

That's only partly true.
There are many big servers that have great content to offer and yet are left abandoned due to lack of players.
Remember all those battleground servers? Those would be amazing if we had enough players to fill them.


user Mora has written
without any explanation or hints

Us developers need a motive to create a feature.
With a lack of players we have a lack of motivation to create proper tutorials (and also CS2D doesn't really have a way to create tutorials easily or efficiently (no information windows, and GUI is just images)).

old Re: CS2D is back boys

ModJuicer
Super User Off Offline

Quote
If that is the case, it's best that it is fixed sooner than later. The more time that passes, the further damage there is to the overall player count. I hope user DC understands the amount of effort people put into making cool mods for the game, just for them to be underappreciated because of design flaws in the game software itself. If it can be fixed, it should be top priority. Fixing the biggest and most neglected problems should be the first step, improving the server list and UI should be close second. CS2D doesn't need to get greenlight on steam just for people to abandon it after playing it for a while. It should be a game that is worthwhile, not a disappointment to people who downloaded it because they thought it looked good in the pictures or videos.

user Mami Tomoe has written
There are many big servers that have great content to offer and yet are left abandoned due to lack of players.
Remember all those battleground servers? Those would be amazing if we had enough players to fill them.


Why did the players leave to begin with though? Were the servers not fun enough? Was it some other factor?

Honestly I think user DC should make a commitment to restart critical development on things in CS2D that have been neglected for far too long. If the system it is designed on is incompatible with improvements, I suggest migrating to a new game engine that works better. It could be an extensive project, but once complete it has the potential to remove many problems, and new features could be added and bugs fixed during such a project. It is better to do that now rather than putting it off until CS2D can no longer be salvaged.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Masea
Super User Off Offline

Quote
Guys... user DC has said it several times already, the game will not get any updates anymore. The last few updates were brought up by user SQ himself anyway. In my opinion, it's been a long time since user DC abandoned this project because he just has no time. Now, get over it, will ya?

By the by, your reasonings are a little ridiculous, no offense. The player base who might potentially start playing this game has no idea if CS2D is modded or not in the first place. And nobody cares whether this game can handle mods like Terraria or GTA replicas without any engine limitations. On the contrary, nobody asks for it. Look at other games that are heavily modded (except Roblox), and look at what people have achieved and made something playable on them. They are not significantly different than the original game itself. So maybe the trick's not about making the best enormous mod out there, right? If you insist on this, the best you can do is recreate the old famous mods such as roleplaying, super hero, gun game, and maybe tibia.

Remaking this game on a newer engine like Unity may help & actually would force you to make a more modern game. Even the fact that this game opens up in a windowed mode the first time you start it, gives the vibe that it may just not be the game to spend your hours on. However, even then, who plays games without auto-matchmaking nowadays? Overwatch has it, Call of Duty has it, hack, even CS:GO has it.

There is a lot to talk about but no time for that hehehe

old Re: CS2D is back boys

GeoB99
Moderator Off Offline

Quote
I am not quite that much active in the forums anymore, unlike in the past years, but one thing I might say is that sometimes I see people tend to complain about the decaying phase of CS2D and its player-base.

In my humble opinion I think all of this reaction is like being in denial, rewriting CS2D in a modern game engine or advertising it across platforms won't solve a thing, because the problem isn't due to this. It may help but this is a very short term effect.

I think the fact that many people have to accept is that CS2D is simply not that attractive to the current gaming demographics anymore as the gaming trend has changed quite a lot in the last decade. The "supply" here simply doesn't fit the "demand" of the people (with "supply" being CS2D in this context). The idea of a Counter-Strike game but in 2D was appealing in the 2010 and early era, but because the gaming trend and the people back then have made it possible that such idea was appealing.

In this era a lot of CS2D based communities were made, lots of players played lots of different servers and many people had a lot of fun being together. It was a moment where lots of young people, kids who lived with parents in basement and played CS2D after school ended. But this was temporary and it was clear the decline was bound to happen sooner or later, the effects have started to be felt by 2017 I presume. The community game-base was made up of mostly youngsters back in 2010 who at this present day are now grown up adults with a career, life goals and other things to focus on. Only a very few nostalgic players have still chosen to get into CS2D, if anything. But others have moved places.

So instead of mourning the old glory of CS2D is gone, be happy because it happened. We all should be thankful of user DC and his efforts brought up to the game, the long support and whatnot. Without him there would not have been communities or people forming bonds and connections around CS2D. Nothing is going to last forever. At this point I would rather keep track on the Stranded III project and on-going development blogs user DC posts.

Just my two cents.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

DC
Admin Off Offline

Quote
Thank you for the kind words user GeoB99.

It's a very good point you have there. To my knowledge CS2D still does run just fine for the majority of people (from a technical point of view). Also there are still more than enough servers available for playing. So what does people stop from playing it?

I don't know but my best guess is that it's either the game(play) which isn't super attractive anymore (because times changed and so on) or that there are now better alternatives. A rewrite most likely wouldn't change either of that. CS2D would still be the same game in the end. Either you want to play it or you don't. Both is okay and we have to accept this.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Xirot
User Off Offline

Quote
Ranked mode.

Genius idea, and could be more bright if we could add the rank on profile under names. But I guess that DC or moderators should host these servers that should be HQ.

@user DC:

old Re: CS2D is back boys

DC
Admin Off Offline

Quote
tldr: @user Mami Tomoe is right. I'm not interested.

Longer version:

Adding a ranked mode to a game with very few players, horrible net code, tons of cheats and without proper cheat detection and without replays? Smart stuff!

This would require a massive time investment for maintenance because you would have to sort out cheaters in some way and handle all the complaints of people who got banned or people who lost against cheaters (all not really possible without replays). Really something I don't want to do. I also really don't want to run and maintain the game servers which would be required for this. You would need a network of trusted servers so you can't (or shouldn't) outsource that to random server owners.

If you still think a ranked mode would be the magic savior for CS2D (I personally don't think so to make that very clear) then you could just go ahead and implement one with Lua. It's definitely possible. Just make a matchmaking server which cs2d cmd reroute's players to match servers based on their ranking. Match servers would have to return the match results to the matchmaking server for rank calculation - which is probably the most complex part but no rocket science either.

Setting this up is the easy part. Maintaining it is the ugly one.
edited 3×, last 19.03.23 04:36:31 pm

old Re: CS2D is back boys

Xirot
User Off Offline

Quote
There are plenty of potentials around that could help with this and for free just because we would like to help to revive this game again.

old Re: CS2D is back boys

DC
Admin Off Offline

Quote
@user Xirot: That's amazing! So if that's true you / the "plenty of potentials" could try what I just explained. You don't need me for this.
To the start Previous 1 2 Next To the start
Log in to replyGeneral overviewCS2D overviewForums overview